It’s that time of year when many start to panic about the inevitable tests that will be given to students all over. And with this panic comes many test-taking strategies that will be told to countless students. I thought I’d share a few of the “secrets” many students are told about how to ace these tests, specifically how to answer any multiple choice sections:

###### Tip #1 – Cover up the 4 answers before you read the question.

Many teachers give advice similar to this asking students to cover up their answers with their hand or with a sticky note… Take a look:

As you can see above, the student covered over the potential answers to help them think through the problem before they start looking for answer. I believe many might suggest this approach when they notice students guessing, or not taking the time and thought necessary to solve a problem. However, I’m not sure this strategy is appropriate for all students, nor will it even work for many questions. How would covering over the answers help here:

Take a look at each of the 6 questions. Which ones would be helpful if your students covered up the answers? Which ones would be impossible? Is this the best strategy for all of your students? Would you use this strategy yourself all the time? Personally, I don’t think I’d ever use this strategy!

I wonder what would happen if we told a group of students to do this every time and they encountered questions like #1 or #2 above? We would be setting them up for failure. Hopefully you are seeing this method might not be possible for every question, nor will all students benefit from using it at all!

###### Tip #2 – Highlight keywords in the question so you know what is being asked of you to do.

Many teachers might ask their students to highlight pieces of a problem or question in order to help them focus their attention on information that might easily be missed.

For the above question, it is possible that some students might miss some of the final words and even though they understand the question, might get their answer wrong. Obviously this isn’t ideal! However, in my experience, many students, even when using a highlighter, miss out on all kinds of information. In the following question, more than half of the students in one classroom answered “d”, even though all of the students were expected to highlight important information. Did so many in this classroom get this question wrong because they were highlighting?

In fact, many of the students in this class highlighted nearly every word of every question. And some of the students who didn’t highlight as many questions as were expected – actually did the best on the test. I’m not suggesting that highlighting is bad, just that it likely didn’t help any/many of the students in this class, and actually got some students to miss out on information and get the wrong answers.

###### Tip #3 – Eliminate the obviously wrong answer first.

Again, many teachers give advice like this because they know it works for them. Take the following question as an example. Would you first eliminate the wrong answers?

Or would you place each of the 4 numbers in the box to see what the answer might be? Or possibly work out the question without notice to the options, then see if your answer is there?

When I watch students think, I typically don’t see students attempting to find the wrong responses. Would it be a feasible strategy for any/some/all of these questions:

###### Some advice.

If you haven’t already read it, please read my post Quick Fixes and Silver Bullets… There I discuss some of the many unproductive beliefs and strategies many schools employ as they attempt to improve testing score, followed by more productive suggestions.

Thinking specifically again about multiple choice questions, there are many different tips we can give students to solve a multiple choice question, but because every question is unique, and every student will have their own thinking and strategies, we might be putting too much emphasis on trying to find the quick fixes and easy answers. Instead of teaching these strategies, I wonder why we don’t just provide students with rich tasks / problems, then encourage more discourse?

If we want our students to do well in our classrooms, we need to make sure we are focusing our attention on providing rich learning opportunities, facilitating meaningful discussions, and consolidating the learning effectively! However, in some classrooms I wonder how much valuable class time is spent preparing for high stakes testing by “practicing” questions that mimic ones found on the test? I wonder how much time is spent seeing IF you understand something instead of time spent on actually learning the curriculum standards the way they were intended to be learned?

**The problem here is that many of these test questions are evidence OF learning, but they are often not the type of experiences needed TO learn the material!**

I think Linda Gojak said it nicely in her NCTM president’s message entitled Are We Obsessed with Assessment?:

###### Final thoughts.

Personally, I’m not a fan of multiple choice questions (see the late Joe Bower’s post for details). In some classrooms there is far too much emphasis on getting right answers on simple questions and far too little emphasis on development of deep understanding of the mathematics! Too many attempt to raise scores by replicating the form and format of the test instead of focusing on the mathematics itself. Yet research shows us the more multiple choice tests we give, the worse our students actually perform on standardized tests!

If you have to help your students prepare for these kinds of tests though, please make sure that you remain focused on the mathematics itself, and not expect all of your students to use YOUR strategies. That’s how you kill your students’ relationship with mathematics! We would never tell our students to pick C for every answer, that will only work 1/4 of the time. In the same way, many of the strategies we provide for our students will not work for all students and not for all questions… and rarely will these strategies actually help them reach our actual goals for our students:

(unless your goals are misguided – like trying to get a certain percentage of students to pass the test – in which case I’m not sure how helpful I’ve been here!).

One other confounding issue (especially for those who use the process of eliminating the wrong answers) is that for a well constructed MC question the wrong answers are based on misconceptions or mistakes. So, for example, in Q#34 on your Tip #3

a) makes the left side equal to 56

b) correct

c) does the 6 – 4 first then multiplies by 31

d) just gets the answer for the right side

Well constructed MC questions are also written so one of the answers (right or wrong) do not stick out. So in that #34 there are two small answers and two large answers.

This is ultimately so that if students get the answer correct or incorrect, you can learn something about what they know or don’t know. Like it or not, this is how EQAO constructs their MC questions. They are trying to make sure that if a student get’s it right or wrong it is for mathematical reasons.

LikeLike

You are correct! Every answer is considered plausible. There will never be an answer that is completely arbitrary.

LikeLike

Having students analyze and reverse engineer distractors intentionally linked to common errors and misconceptions is a powerful and enabling strategy for strengthening conceptual understanding.

LikeLike

Great point Jay! Any time we can discuss mathematics together can make for great learning opportunities. Not sure I would tell every student to do this for every question though.

LikeLike